There’s a lot of conversation surrounding Todd Duffee (6-0 MMA, 1-0 UFC), and there should be. He broke the long standing UFC record for fastest knockout in UFC history when he put away Tim Hague (10-4 MMA, 1-3 UFC) in seven seconds. I’ve done a little bit of the history already, but it’s worth noting that the two fighters who originally set those fastest times, Don Frye (20-8-1-1 MMA, 9-1 UFC) and, before that, Gerard Gordeau (2-2 MMA, 2-1 UFC), did so in their UFC debuts as well.
It seems to me, there’s an argument to be made that Duffee might be something like Frye, who was a dangerous striker in a division ruled by wrestlers, but I think that argument doesn’t really represent Duffee, who’s more equipped to fight off of his back than Frye ever was. There are reports that Duffee is a Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu blackbelt (though not under a particularly well known lineage, so I’m skeptical) but that’s not what’s interesting, to me.
Duffee is 25 years old, which makes him the youngest of the serious heavyweight prospects. Like Duffee, Cain Velasquez (8-0 MMA, 6-0 UFC, #4 IWMMAR) debuted in the UFC at 24 and put up a phenomenal performance which drew some attention (though less than Duffee’s) but what was most impressive about Velasquez was the hype which surrounded, not his wrestling pedigree, but his ability to learn and develop physically in the gym. I have a suspicion that Duffee is similar.
Duffee will be stepping into the cage against Mike Russow (12-1 MMA, 1-0 UFC) who was the rumored opponent for Duffee’s debut. Russow fought on the same card as Duffee, posting his first win over Justin McCully (9-5-2 MMA, 2-2 UFC) by Unanimous Decision. I suppose there’s something to be said about how a fighter wins, because Duffee is stepping into the cage a substantial favorite over Russow, a fighter with more bouts and a similar UFC record. Russow will be a serious challenger for Duffee, given his extensive experience against international level competition, though there’s a reasonable defense of calling Duffee a favorite, and that’s what’s worth touching on next.
A lot of the young guys in the UFC heavyweight division are really unknown commodities. That’s not to say we don’t know who they are or where their skills come from, but we don’t know what their limitations are. Duffee, Velasquez and even an older guy like Shane Carwin (12-0 MMA, 4-0 UFC, #3 IWMMAR) become hard to judge when they haven’t been pushed to a point where their limitations become visible. We see glimpses, like the knockdown blow Carwin took from Gabriel Gonzaga (11-5 MMA, 7-4 UFC) but it’s not the same as watching an attrition war, where we’re presented with a ton of information about the skills and weaknesses of a fighter.
The jury is out on Duffee. He may be a flash in a pan (or even a few flashes) but he may also prove to be a versatile, developing talent. His physique and athleticism certainly allow for him becoming a force in a UFC heavyweight division that seems to be growing physically. However, it also allows that those wins might have been rooted in physical power, and that his dependence on that athleticism in the gym limits his training. We should keep our fingers crossed for the former, of course, but don’t cast judgment on either side too quickly. If Duffee really is working with the heavyweights at Xtreme Couture and learning from the phenomenal coaching staff there, he could be a serious force in the division, but this long awaited return is still a major moment in Duffee’s career, because whatever he does is going to be scrutinized, and a poor performance will diminish his value in the eyes of many of the fans looking for prospects.
News
mma, Todd Duffee, UFC 114